Hi, I have checked both videos, I am a 3D Artist and also work professionally with Aftereffect, I suggest a combination of them, I have many professional car models that I can place this product on them and give realistic renders, this can be mixed with renders to show its flexibility and different views. I can create scratches on surfaces with 3D renders. no need for a real scene.
Finally, I will add all 2D Animation Items needed for finalizing the videos. I do not need color codes, I will get them from the video. Also, I can create more complex materials like metallic and matte car colors.